The traditional gift for a first anniversary might not be the most glamorous, but it is practical. Paper gifts include fine stationery, tickets to a cultural or sporting event, or something more unique. Be different and purchase a framed share of stock in the name of the husband and wife. You can even add a personal message to the plaque, such as “Happy 1st Anniversary – hope your stock splits but you don’t” or “Have a Bullish 1st Anniversary!”